patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Readers Sound Off About Pit Bull Proposal

We've gotten a lot of comments on the issue. We thought we'd share some of the best.

 

A measure introduced by Lakewood City Council meant to clarfiy the language in a 2008 ban on pit bulls has opened some old wounds.

Lakewood Patch readers — not usually silent on issues in the community — have let their voices be heard.

Although the legislation was tabled until council reconvenes from its summer break, the discussion on Lakewood Patch continues.

We thought we'd share a few of the best comments.

"Let's get rid of the words "pit bulls" and substitute them for "animals showing dangerous anti-social behavior, such as biting." (I've known some great pit bulls too)" -Sandy

"There are 3 pit bulls on my street. My dogs and husband have been attacked. My husband was severely wounded and underwent surgery We incurred high medical bills and my husband was out of work for 7 months after surgery. The dog had attacked 3 other times before this attack. The homeowners left my husband lying in the street, neighbors had to call 911. I cannot walk north or south on my street without passing a pitbull residence. We still have not been compensated by homeowners insurance but I am so relieved they were Forced to carry that rider on their insurance. The homeowners got to keep their dog. They were to relocate it but snuck it back to their home on my street. They still got to keep the dog. These dogs affect the neighborhood as a whole, no other "pets" are afforded such run of the city. I can honestly say with the number of pitbulls in my neighborhood, I am always nervous walking my street." - Jill Gefert

"There is NO way to visually identify a Pit Bull. I have 4 dogs, all of which have been identified as a Pit Bull at one time or another. 1 is a Pit Bull. One is a mix that was labeled a "Pit Bull" by the pound vet. I did a DNA test on her and.....she is NOT a Pit Bull. One is a Springer Spaniel. With a short "field cut" she was identified as a Pit Bull, despite the long ears. One is an "Olde English Bulldogge." This one is almost always called a Pit Bull despite the fact that she is far stronger than most Pit Bulls and doesn't resemble a Pit much at all. Another is a real Pit Bull. He likes BBQ and beer and just likes to hang out, really. He would NOT bite a human. Fighting Pits that bite humans are considered worthless, even in the "Ghetto," and are destroyed. Any dog will bite, hang on, and shake its head. Any dog is dangerous if starved and neglected." -Mike Pfaff

"In my humble opinion ... putting the burden of proof on the dog owner (the "accused") is contradictory to how our judicial system operates." -Peter Grossetti

"How can you put the blame on a whole breed of dog? You're telling me every single pit bull is going to attack someone? What about other dogs that attacked someone...just because they are not "pit bulls" there is no punishment? How about hold the owners responsible the ones that didn't take the time to train, socialize and care for their dogs which lead to unwanted act? Blaming a entire breed for a few misguided dogs is no different than someone proposing to ban a race of human based on statistics that say they commit more crimes and take up a larger proportion of correctional facilities! But maybe that's the reason lakewood is pushing this dog ban because they can't out right ban people so they think only races of color own pit bulls which would force out their unwanted people. You people need to actually do research and learn a few things because you're trying to get rid of a breed that ranks higher than 90 percent of all dog breeds in the united states temperament test. Open your eyes people you're punishing good citizens with this ordinance. Bsl is no answer to solving any dog or irresponsible dog owner problem." -Brad

"As soon as the city of Lakewood passed its ban, I refused to shop or eat there because I did not want any of my money in the form of taxes coming back to the city to support such ridiculous legislation. I would not live there and I've steered friends away from purchasing homes there whenever possible.

I've been bitten by dogs four times in my life, three of which required trips to the emergency room: one from a chihuahua, one from a miniature dachshund and one from a mixed breed mutt. I've rescued pit bull dogs for 10 years. Dogs that have been fought, beaten, abused, burned, knifed, starved, nearly frozen to death... Despite being in pain in the most horrendous situations imaginable, I've never been bitten by one of those dogs.

Dog bites occur because of owner neglect and inattention and ignorance on the part of the person interacting with the dog. No dog (or cat, actually) should be allowed to roam. No dog should be kept chained for hours at a time. Dogs need appropriate exercise. Those are all things that the owners of any type of dog should be cognizant of. Unaltered dogs (not spayed or neutered) are responsible for most fatal dog attacks, regardless of breed.

You cannot legislate dog behavior. You only can legislate the behavior of people, something Lakewood continues to ignore. Lakewood Council should check out Cleveland's new vicious dog ordinance if they're truly interested in public safety." -Sandy Smith

Related Topics: BSL, Lakewood pit bull ban, Pit bull ban, breed specific legislation, and pit bulls
Care to join the discussion? What do you think about issue? Tell us in the comments.

Chef David Edelstein M

12:32 pm on Wednesday, August 10, 2011

I have been directly involved in over 50 rescues (all breeds), driven over 5000 rescue transport miles, have directly been invoved with over a dozen rehab/reconditioning of abused/ neglected dogs (all breeds) and have 6 dogs (1 great dane, 4 pit bulls, and 1 aussie/ border mix). I have been bitten by a dog twice in my life... 1 Min Pin, and 1 GSD. Neither should be considered "vicious" or "a threat to public safety". The dogs need training and responsible ownership... plain and simple. Anyone who believes that banning or restricting 1 entire breed in hopes of achieving public safety needs to shove their head back in the sand where it belongs. You are clueless as to common sense and anything remotely resembling constructive animal welfare efforts. Yes, I am referring to you Mr. and Mrs. John Doe Politician. Stick to what you know best... back room bargaining and alternative agenda. Leave genuine public issues to the big boys.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Gwen Lebec

2:34 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

It is the job of John Doe Politician to protect the members of their community and "big boys" like you are not doing anything to protect the children that do get mauled. The fact that most pit type dogs don't maul or kill does not negate the suffering of the victims who are attacked. It is ridiculous to argue that it is okay for children or anyone to suffer these maulings so that you pit lovers are not inconvenienced. If you don't want bans, then offer some real solutions. But all you "big boys" who use language like that to defend your ownership of pits just indicates that perhaps you need for your dog to provide your own "big boy" image.

Comment_arrow

Chef David Edelstein M

3:33 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Oh Qwen.... ye of little brain cells. Your argument is about 20 years too late. Since you seem to know it all, then why dont you know it all yourself right onto google and search the terms "generalized dangerous dog ordinance". Its a little something that HSUS, ASPCA, American Veterinary Medicine Association, American Humane Association, AKC, UKC, RSPCA, Animal Farm Foundation, LA Animal Foundation, The Center For Disease Control and Prevenetion, and Best Friends Animal Society came up with a couple of decades ago. It takes the focus/ liability off the individual animal and places it where it belongs: On The Irresponsible Owner (who abuses his/ her dog, neglects the dogs needs, trains the dog to fight, trains the dog to attack, chains the dog in the backyard for MANY YEARS at a time, neglects the dogs medical need, over breeds the dog for their own personal profit... thus creating a dangerous animal in the first place.)
Cities like Los Angeles, New York, Chicago, St Paul, Sacreamento and several others have been using them for years. Funny thing, incidents in those cities are far and few inbetween.
Ya wanna go toe to toe with me about the absolute fallacy that the is inherently more dangerous than other breeds? Bring it...

Comment_arrow

Chef David Edelstein M

3:40 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Unlike the sever mis-informed like yourself, Ive done my research for years and can say without a doubt that the breed WAS NOT ORIGINALLY BRED FOR FIGHTING... rather, hearding live stock in the Bristish Isles circa 1500ad, The Pit Bull breed(s) are 110% incapable of locking their jaws, The breeds dont "suddenly snap" nor do their brains swell, and (get your little crayon and paper ready)... 9.5 out of 10 times the media [newspapers or tv news] reports a "PIT BULL ATTACK"... it doesnt even involve a pit bull at all.
(I can hear the squeaky gears turning... am I right? )
"THEN WHY DO THEY REPORT IT AS A PIT BULL WHEN IT WASNT?" Would you tune in or pick up a paper with the headline "Pit Bull Sleeps on Couch" or "Unknown breed Attacks Child?" No, of course not... because you are sheople and are a victim of the US MASS MEDIA. You want to hear about blood and gore and death. Your attention span stretches to MAYBE your finger tips and you wouldnt read or listen to a story without the hype and sensationalism. As long as those that are thick between the ears (like? YOU!!!) keep reading or tuning in, the media will keep on ramming mis-information and SENSATIONALIZED stories down your throat.

Comment_arrow

Chef David Edelstein M

3:52 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

If you GENUINELY want to do the public a service (instead of playing the part of internet heroism)... turn off your computer and go OUT THERE and meet a responsible pit bull owner and meet their dogs. Grill them with questions, ask about Canine Good Citizen Certification, ask what other breeds their dog plays with or EVEN lives with, ask what their typical day consists of (oddly, it will sound IDENTICAL to that of a Labradore or German Shepherd or Yorkie or Healer owner) and... if you dare... get down on the ground and introduce yourself to the dog and vice verse. BE CAREFULL THOUGH... you might get licked to death or hugged into oblivion.

How do I know the results of this endeavor? Been there/ done that/ brought back the tshirt... and I am the owner of 6 dogs (1 great dane, 4 pit bulls, and 1 Aussie/ Border Mix) and speak from PERSONAL HANDS ON experience. The trouble maker in our pack is the Aussie... and even she is kept under control 150% of the time.
Our pack is well fed, they are taught the rules and boundaries, they have no medical needs, they are NEVER chained up in the back yard, they are socialized with people (yes, even children) and other animals daily, they get too much exercise (if there is such a thing) and they are included as part of our family.

Comment_arrow

Chef David Edelstein M

3:54 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Until you KNOW FOR A FACT what you are talking about and have done actual research and experienced personal hands on experience, you are nothing but an ugly internet troll begging for attention.

Comment_arrow

Chef David Edelstein M

4:10 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Ya wanna go toe to toe with me on the roll of politicians when it comes pit bulls and public safety? Bring it on. I warn you though, you will crawl away bloody. You are the nothing. Ive gone at it with city officials from So Calif to Florida and their argument is always the same: a complete failure and it reveals they have public safety least on their agenda. All they know is they want to get re-elected and creating fear and then getting the problem as far away from the community as possible will get keep them in office.
Lets use Denver, CO as an example since widespread fear and legislation specific to Pit Bulls started in Denver in the late 1980's. Get Your Crayon Ready Again: The ONLY reason Denver continues to enforce a Pit Bull Ban is their Home Rule Authority. They have no credible experts, they have no valid documentation (at least none that hasnt been slanted or tampered with), they waste $803,170 annually on an ordinance that has been PROVEN ineffective, ALL major animal welfare organizations denounce Denver and their BSL practices, and the city is continuously sued for their ban (and yes, they lose 99% of the time). Ive engaged their city council and mayor and their argument dwindles down to the same thing every time: "We are a Home Rule City and no one will tell us what to do". THATS IT, no more. No leading animal behaviorists, no factual statistics, no legitimate polling of their registered voters, NOTHING. Just ego.

Comment_arrow

Sheela Na Gig

9:36 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

You, by your own definition are a troll. You know nothing. Pit bulls were not created until the 1830s. There are other older fighting breeds from other countries, but in britain - 1830s. And yes I know that for a fact. Look it up.

Your 9.5 of 10 pit bull identifications wrong? Prove it. There is no such research.

Every single community that has BSL also has generalized dangerous dog laws that cover all other types of dogs - it is not an either or proposition. Look it up.

Comment_arrow

Sheela Na Gig

9:42 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Here's a list of Large and small cities with successful BSL. Please note, these are NOT interest groups these are CITY LEADERS, POLICE CHIEFS, ANIMAL CONTROL OFFICERS, and MUNICIPAL LAWYERS who are saying that BSL is a proven success, these LAWS WORK, are AFFORDABLE, and provide an IMPROVED QUALITY OF LIFE for citizens. Every single listing is cited and sourced if you have an doubts.

http://blog.dogsbite.org/2010/06/cities-with-successful-pit-bull-laws.html

Comment_arrow

Sheela Na Gig

9:54 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Hospitalizations Resulting from Dog Bite Injuries -- Alaska, 1991-2002, compiled by Louisa Castrodale, Int J Circumpolar Health, 2007 Sep;66(4):320-7.

Nonfatal Dog Bite--Related Injuries Treated in Hospital Emergency Departments --- United States, 2001, by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR), 2003; 52(26): 605-610.
Incidence of Dog Bite Injuries Treated in Emergency Departments (1992-1994), by Harold B. Weiss, MS, MPH; Deborah I. Friedman; Jeffrey H. Coben, MD., Journal of American Medical Association (JAMA), 1998:279-1.

Dog Bites: How Big of a Problem?, by Sacks JJ, Kresnow M, Houston B, Injury Prevention, 1996; 2:52-54.
Mauling by Pit Bull Terriers: Case Report, by Baack BR, Kucan JO, Demarest G, Smoot EC, Journal of Trauma-Injury Infection & Critical Care, 29(4):517-520, April 1989.

Pit Bull Attack: Case Report and Literature Review, by Steven F. Vegas, MD, Jason H. Calhoun, MD, M. Eng., John Mader, MD, Texas Medicine, Vol. 84, November 1988.

Comment_arrow

Sheela Na Gig

9:54 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Bites, Animal (Catastrophic Pit Bull Attack Injury), by Alisha Perkins Garth, MD, Coauthor(s): N Stuart Harris, MD, FACEP, eMedicine, Updated: June 25, 2009.

Omental Free-Tissue Transfer for Coverage of Complex Upper Extremity and Hand Defects--The Forgotten Flap, by Iris A. Seitz, Craig S. Williams, Thomas A. Wiedrich, Ginard Henry, John G. Seiler and Loren S. Schechte, PubMed, March 25, 2009.

Head and Neck Dog Bites in Children, by Angelo Monroy, MD, Philomena Behar, MD, Mark Nagy, MD, Christopher Poje, MD, Michael Pizzuto, MD, and Linda Brodsky, MD, Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery, 140, 354-357 2009.

A Ten-Year, Two-Institution Review of Pediatric Dog Attacks: Advocating for a Nationwide Prohibition of Dangerous Dogs, by Jugpal S. Arneja, MD, FRCSC, Kara Pappas, B.S., William Huettner, M.D., Arlene A. Rozzelle, M.D., Gurbalbir Singh, M.D., FRCSC., American Association of Plastic Surgeons - 2008 Annual Meeting

Pitbull Mauling Deaths in Detroit, by Cheryl L. Loewe MD, Francisco J. Diaz MD, and John Bechinski DO, The American Journal of Forensic Medicine and Pathology, Vol 28, December 2007.

Comment_arrow

Sheela Na Gig

9:54 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

When medical professionals, trauma care surgeons, doctors, nurses, hospitals and medical institutions have done independent, peer reviewed studies, they all find the same things. Pit bulls inflict a disproportionate number of severe maulings and maimings and deaths. And their maulings and maimings are infinitely more severe than any other kind of dog.

Mortality, Mauling, and Maiming by Vicious Dogs, by John K. Bini, MD, Stephen M. Cohn, MD, Shirley M. Acosta, RN, Marilyn J. McFarland, RN, MS, Mark T. Muir, MD and Joel E. Michalek, PhD; for the TRISAT Clinical Trials Group, Annals of Surgery, April 2011 - Volume 253 - Issue 4 - p 791–797

Emergency Department Visits and Inpatient Stays Involving Dog Bites, 2008, by Laurel Holmquist, M.A. and Anne Elixhauser, Ph.D., Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, Rockville, MD., November 2010.

Pediatric Dog Bite Injuries: A 5-Year Review of the Experience at The Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, by Kaye, Alison E. M.D.; Belz, Jessica M. M.D.; Kirschner, Richard E. M.D., Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, August 2009 - Volume 124 - Issue 2 - pp 551-558.

debbie bell

1:54 pm on Wednesday, August 10, 2011

"He would NOT bite a human," was written by one pit bull owner.

Ideas like this, from any dog owner, show that the dog owner is naive. Naive dog owners are a threat to the community.

"Dog bites occur because of owner neglect and inattention and ignorance on the part of the person interacting with the dog."

Tragically with pit bulls, neither of these statements are true. Pit bulls were specifically bred to NOT give warning, to NOT try to avoid a fight, to NOT (imo) even know when they were going to attack. Surprise attacks helped win dog fights, so those were the traits that were bred for.

Many pit bull websites recommend that pits always be separated when no human is present to stop a fight, even between BFF dogs. If pits can go from snuggling to killing their "sister" dogs in a matter of moments, we should not be surprised if a pit suddenly gets the Instinct (instinct means no training required) to suddenly begin tugging and crushing with its jaws. It is only doing what humans created it to do.

Let them become extinct thru free mandatory spay/neuter/ microchipping. Everybody wins, especially the overpopulated, abused, tortured, neglected, dying pit bulls.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Kristi

9:54 am on Saturday, August 13, 2011

Debbie: With all due respect, it is quite obvious that you are yet another person who speaks as though she knows what she's talking about, and yet speaks nothing but inaccuracies, myths, and untruths. It seems you're talking solely about "pit bulls" bred for dog fighting. What you obviously don't know is that, while some "pit bulls" are bred to fight other dogs, those same "pit bulls" are also specifically bred not to attack humans. This is because humans are standing around everywhere during fights and the owners of the dogs have to get in the ring to break up fights. Again, fighting dogs are bred NOT TO ATTACK HUMANS! Also, how in the world can you breed a dog to not give a warning? That's so ridiculous. Warning signs include stiff raised tail, raised hackles, direct eye contact, snarling and sometimes barking. Again, I ask, how can you breed these things out of a dog? Can you breed a dog not to raise its tail or raise its hackles? No. Also, a dog does not suddenly get an instinct to do anything. Instinct is inate - built-in. Not something he suddenly acquires. Perhaps you can do a little research and educate yourself before you comment again. For those of us who actually know what we're talking about, or who own and love "pit bulls", that's not too much to ask.

Comment_arrow

Chef David Edelstein M

8:07 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

hey dimwhit, I MEAN DEBBIE... where do you find this crap? Wickipedia? You are NOT in Rescue. You know NOT what responsible Pit Bull owners are all about. You know NOT a damned thing about me or my dogs.
YES, I admit it... my dog WILL BITE. They have been trained to protect themselves from anyone abusing them (ie beating on them, trying to steel them, anyone tormenting them, etc). Have they ever bitten anyone? No, not in the past 4 years since I have had them. Have they shown signs of attacking? Absolutely... when an aggressive dog approaches them and is picking a fight... they are MORE THAN CLEAR ON THEIR INTENTIONS.
They are also CGC certified and visit school children (yes at the permission of their parents, teachers and school districts) where we teach being kind to animals, responsible ownership, how to properly interact with dogs, and what ignorance (you know lots about that) can do to a community.
You need to pull your head out of your own ass and learn some true facts about a breed prior to jumping online and spewing your ignorance for the world to see.

Comment_arrow

Sheela Na Gig

10:10 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

THE chef is a moron. He claims, "YES, I admit it... my dog WILL BITE. They have been trained to protect themselves from anyone abusing them (ie beating on them, trying to steel them, anyone tormenting them, etc)."

How exactly do you "train" your dogs to bite if abused? Right.

Kristi - The way you do that is the way you breed for any behavior. You breed the dogs that best show that behavior. Dogfighters weren't geneticists or even smart. They just bred the dogs that could get the job done the best.

here is a video of two pit bulls that show no sign that they're going to fight before they begin to fight. They barely seem to be paying attention to each other, in fact before they attack (and yes the shelter workers are idiots):
http://www.wreg.com/news/wreg-dog-fight-memphis-animal,0,1443142.story

debbie bell

1:57 pm on Wednesday, August 10, 2011

If it is illegal for me to rush up to you as you walk by my house, stab you repeatedly and hack off chunks of flesh, why is it legal for me to intentionally acquire and own a breed of dog that was intentionally created to do essentially the same thing?

Pit bulls are the choice of dog fighters for a reason: they are the best at it.

Even if dogs were the only victims of the pit bull breed abilities and instincts to maim and maul, why would anyone who really cares about dogs want the dog aggression experts to continue to be produced? Let these mauling masters gradually become extinct.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Jo Angle Staats

5:24 pm on Wednesday, August 10, 2011

The ACT of rushing up stabbing repeatedly and hacking off chunks of flesh is what is illegal...not the knife you use to do it with.

Does that give you a clearer understanding?

Its also illegal to drive while under the influence, however cars are not outlawed.

The 'instinct' that you refer to has been (repeatedly) removed from [legal] argument by scientists across the board. There's no such thing as a monogamy gene—or, for that matter, a gene for altruism or aggression.

"It's a very interactive interdependency among genes, environment, and behavior." - Marla Sokolowski

Comment_arrow

Chef David Edelstein M

6:26 pm on Wednesday, August 10, 2011

Jo... YOU KNOW I am on the same page, but for credibility sake... can you supply a a URL where that quote was pulled from? You know me, I am all about dropping the power bomb of knowledge and verifiable facts on those who find themselves intellectually challenged in our modern times.

Comment_arrow

Kristi

10:01 am on Saturday, August 13, 2011

Debbie - you finally said something right, i.e., that "pit bulls" are the choice of dog fighters for a reason. I'm quite sure, however, that you have no idea what that reason is. The reason is that they are easy to train. They are smart, loyal, more eager than any other breeds to please their owners, and less likely to attack their human owners even while being abused, tortured, and neglected. I wish that people who have no idea what they're talking about, and still feel compelled to spew ridiculous statements on internet blogs would become instinct - and soon!

Comment_arrow

Jo Angle Staats

2:42 pm on Monday, August 15, 2011

Sorry Chef, I haven't followed this over the weekend! I was out in the world enjoying my pit bulls! lol ;-)

But yes, I can provide a link to the genetic study that I quoted above:
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/nature/genes-behavior.html

Even if we were to lend a second thought to the anti-pit haters of the world Chef, and believe for a moment that the breeds piled into the lump term pit bull were inherently dangerous, this study also illustrates how environment and nurture sparks the variables feeding the genetic reasctions.

Also, another study released last year (http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1952313,00.html) denounces the theory that anti-pit haters constantly spew on the general public about how for generations these dogs are bred to be the vicious dog-killing-machines that they want the public to see them as (to further their campaign(s) to eradicate the breeds). This study shows that within a single generation of reproduction, genetics are affected by environment/nurture.

These are just two studies that have been released that absolutely denounces the 'inheritance' argument. But they're both extremely clear and precise that there is NO validity to their 'old' argument!

Peter Grossetti

2:05 pm on Wednesday, August 10, 2011

why is it legal for me to intentionally acquire a gun that was intentionally created to kill people?

Reply

debbie bell

2:11 pm on Wednesday, August 10, 2011

"I have been bitten by a dog twice in my life... 1 Min Pin, and 1 GSD. Neither should be considered "vicious" or "a threat to public safety". "

You have never been mauled by a neighbor's pit bull that pushed out the front door past the 8 year old child to latch onto the right side of your face, and then not let go.

I'm not talking about the average dog bite. I'm talking about the masters who can do great damage, who sometimes won't let go (can't let go, because of instinct).

We need a "pit bull neighbor time share", so you can live on the same block with aggressive intact dogs, on chains or behind flimsy fences, and get to know the world of the pit bull, the total pit bull experience... including the fear for your dogs and for yourself.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Peter Grossetti

2:15 pm on Wednesday, August 10, 2011

and we need a "gun-toting time share," too.

Comment_arrow

Kristi

10:08 am on Saturday, August 13, 2011

Debbie - "the total pit bull experience", huh? Well, I own a pit bull. I've had her for 5 years now. She was rescued from a fighting ring. I have and/or still do volunteer for pit bull only or pit bull friendly rescues. My dog - who is an AKC Certified Canine Good Citizen - and I attended pit bull only training classes which included a dozen pit bulls and their owners in 1 small room for hours. I am an attorney, who for the past 2 years or so, has specialized in pit bull issues, including BSL. In doing so, I have spoken with pit bull experts all over the country (people who actually know what they're takling about, including doctors, Ph.D.s, behaviorists, trainers, published authors, etc.). My husband, who is also an attorney - and I have been successful in getting BSL overturned in Toledo, OH, one of the worst places for these breeds in Ohio. I have reviewed thousands of documents from cities all over Ohio discussing bites caused by dogs, including pit bulls. I think that qualifies as the "total pit bull experience". Simply put, you're wrong and uneducated about this topic. Stop blogging about it.

Peter Grossetti

2:12 pm on Wednesday, August 10, 2011

time for a gun ban in Lakewood ... they have caused more public safety issues than any dog has.

Reply

Peter Grossetti

2:27 pm on Wednesday, August 10, 2011

FYI, Pach readers, debbie bell has posted the same "information" on patch sites discussing this topic across the country from Connecticut to California. Smells like Spam to me.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Chef David Edelstein M

2:53 pm on Wednesday, August 10, 2011

Peter... I believe she is not spam... rather another mis-informed lemming from the www.Dogsbite.org camp of ignorance and propaganda.

Comment_arrow

debbie bell

7:34 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Pit bull promoters often use diversionnary techniques. What does it matter if I post a lot? I've trying to educate the public, since the pit bull promoters are happy with misleading propaganda. At least I use my real name.

I don't try to mislead anyone. And I'm very different from the pit bull promoters. I truly care about dog welfare. Pit bull promoters only care about themselves. The suffering of pits doesn't even appear in their radar, the suffering of the pit's victims (dogs, cats, children) doesn't make them bat an eye. More pits, more suffering dying pits, hey, no problem!
A honest pit bull promoter would say "I'm happy and that's all that matters" .

Comment_arrow

Chef David Edelstein M

8:15 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Dimwit (Debbie)... first of all, Im not selling concert tickets.... there for I am not a "promoter". What I am is a resonsible multiple Pit Bull owner who advocates the breed and responsible ownership of the breed.
As for diversions... not once have I strayed from the topic. YOU DIMWIT are the one who keeps attempting new arguments when FACTS shut you down.

Everything that girggles out of your mouth is misleading. Nothing you have said is based on facts while EVERYTHING pro-Pit Bull/ responsible ownership advocates have shared on this thread is pure, unadulterated fact... verifiable even.

As for caring about ourselves... you are correct. ALL we care about is ourselves, and our dogs, and ALL DOGS and safety in the community. You betcha... we are selfish to the core. As in... if someone like you dropped dead tomorrow from a mass corniary... too bad, so sad, bye bye. There would be one less Nazi in the world trying to kill off which they have not a clue about.

Do us a favor... go back to the 1950's where you belong.

Chef David Edelstein M

2:51 pm on Wednesday, August 10, 2011

@ debbie bell... Obviously, you live in a place with a surplus of irresponsible owners. Instead of your witch hunt for a breed of dog you obviously know NOTHING ABOUT (hun, the orginal molasoid dog [ancestor to the modern day staffordshire bull terrier] was bred to herd live stock, flush rodents, and protect families on remote farms and ranches in the British Isle circa 1500ad... its common knowledge, do a google search) Try placing blame where it belongs: Irresponsible Humans. If I were to move to your neighborhood, I would have HSUS, ASPCA, and Local A/C set up a satelite station so they can start arresting these owners for abuse and neglect. Yes, these are crimes and punishable in a court of law. Get really familiar with www.Pet-Abuse.com, follow the cases, read the chart that defines law by state, etc. Lastly, careful there missy, your dark age mentality is showing. ALL PIT BULL OWNERS tether their dogs? ALL PIT BULL OWNERS train their dogs to attack? ALL PIT BULL OWNERS are gang bangers, drug dealers, thugs or white trash? Hm, so Im not a 29 year veteran Chef making a very descent living, living in a very affluent neighborhood, and I dont come from an ultra conservative family from New England?

Reply
Comment_arrow

debbie bell

7:26 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Chef: ALL PIT BULL OWNERS tether their dogs? ALL PIT BULL OWNERS train their dogs to attack? ALL PIT BULL OWNERS are gang bangers, drug dealers, thugs or white trash?

I never said any of those things. I do say that the pit bull breed is unpredictable, because pit bulls were bred to be unpredictable.

Watch the Russian fox videos. Watch any herding dog demo. These are instincts and behaviors created by humans thru selective breeding over the generations. FACT.

I have personally seen a pit bull go from calm and friendly to biting and not letting go. It is not the dog's fault. He was bred to behave that way.
Unless your dream is to have the best fighting dog, the pit bull fighting instincts are no longer needed. Let them gradually become extinct.

No one has ever said to me "I really need to find a Tweed Water Spaniel, that's the only breed for me". The TWS was an early ancestor of the Golden Retriever, that officially is now extinct. Extinct isn't so bad. Being treated the way pits are being treated now is very bad.

Dobes and GSD's never were acquired/suffering in the numbers and for the horrible uses that pit bulls are now.

Comment_arrow

Chef David Edelstein M

8:19 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Yes you did in implicating that ALL PIT BULLS ARE UNPREDICTABLE AND TRAINED TO ATTACK. Those are not traits known to the Pit Bull Breeds at all. Those traits are trained into them by irresponsible owners... there for if ALL PIT BULLS exibit a certain behavior (BREED WIDE)... then all Pit Bulls were trained to do so by irresponsible Pit Bull Owners... so in fact you are saying ALL PIT BULL OWNERS are the bad element and have trained ALL PIT BULLS to exibiti certain behaviors.

(This isnt even fair... someone give me a REAL opponent in this argument)

Peter Grossetti

2:58 pm on Wednesday, August 10, 2011

Chef - in my book, "propaganda" = "Spam." :)

Reply
Comment_arrow

Chef David Edelstein M

3:23 pm on Wednesday, August 10, 2011

well, sort of. Propaganda is blatant lies and mis-information while modern day spam (not the kind some people eat) is typically marketing scams. But I see your point... its both a whole lot of noise that our society could do without.

Steve

3:09 pm on Wednesday, August 10, 2011

Debbie Bell, it is people like you that really scare me. You have a Hittler attitude of makeing things extinct that are beyond your comprehension. You are the real safety issue, just waiting to go off..scarry thought. I would love to see a live dinosaur, but you would probably condemn it to death, in the name of public safety.

Reply
Comment_arrow

debbie bell

7:10 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

You are right, I would not like my neighbors to have a T rex behind a flimsy fence or chained to a tree. But I guess you are saying that would be fine with you?

Comment_arrow

Chef David Edelstein M

8:23 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

sen·sa·tion·al·ism   /sɛnˈseɪʃənlˌɪzəm/ Show Spelled[sen-sey-shuh-nl-iz-uhm] Show IPA
noun
1. subject matter, language, or style producing or designed to produce startling or thrilling impressions or to excite and please vulgar taste.
2. the use of or interest in this subject matter, language, or style: The cheap tabloids relied on sensationalism to increase their circulation.

The context in which " T REX" is used... I dont think you could have hit the true definition of sensationalism any closer.

Nice try... We're still not buying your BS.

Comment_arrow

Steve

6:42 pm on Monday, August 15, 2011

You do realise that some donosaurs were only 6 inches tall and ate only vegatation. Funny how you came up with a t-rex, always going for the badest of the bad. If I lived next door to you, I might change my mind an get one of them big lizzards instead.

Nic

6:47 pm on Wednesday, August 10, 2011

I am a cancer survivor. All the dogs in the therapy program were pit bulls. There were children who did not survive their battle with cancer and their very last wish was to hold their therapy pit bull in their arms as they left this world. I was badly mauled on my left arm by a Black Lab. The dog almost severed my arm in half between my wrist and elbow. It was the worst dog attack the hospital had ever seen. I have nerve damage and am numb and my arm is a horror to look at. Some people have almost thrown up, so I now keep it covered. Should we ban Black Labs? Debbie Bell - all that you wrote are blatent LIES and all the statistics and studies and research show that you are a LIAR. Please see http://www.nationalcanineresearchcouncil.com/ for the truth about dog bites. Pit bulls test higher than Golden Retrievers and over 180 other breeds in temperament tests - see http://atts.org/. Pit bulls are ranked #1 for children and were orignally called the nanny dog. Pit bulls are the most people-orientated breed and are the most loyal, loving and affectionate dogs. Debbie Bell - contact me and I will pay for you to fly out to NY and will bring you to the cancer unit to meet the therapy pit bulls. I will also introduce you to the thousands of parents whose children suffered cancer and benefited from the therapy pit bulls. They will tell you what they think of your lies and garbage. It is all on me therefore you have nothing to lose. We need to ban bad people who abuse these dogs.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Gwen Lebec

2:30 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

All nice information but it ignores the real fact that when a pit bull type dog does attack it is more likely to be a severe mauling or fatal than if a Golden Retriever bites someone. I would rather be bitten 10 times by a Chihuahua than once by a pit bull. How about you?

Comment_arrow

debbie bell

7:16 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Should we ban Black Labs? I never said to ban a dog. I said spay/neuter.

I think the black lab that attacked you should have been spayed or neutered, too.

Comment_arrow

debbie bell

7:39 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Nic wrote: contact me and I will pay for you to fly out to NY

Instead, how about posting on CraigList "will take your unwanted pit bull types and not euthanize them, but will find them good longlasting homes."

In most communities pits are being killed or turned away to fates worse than death. Best Friends, well known for Dog Town, turns away thousands of animals every month (email/phone call). There is no hope for many pit bulls. Pits are breeding much faster than good homes can be found, faster than shelters could be built. Free, mandatory spay/neuter microchipping is the kind answer.

Comment_arrow

debbie bell

7:58 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Even the ATTS says it is not a predictor of future behavior. From the ATTS website: "The pass-fail rate is not a measure of a breed’s aggression." Guess a breed that passed with 100% of the dogs tested? The American Tunnel Terrier, but only two dogs were tested in 2010. Not an predictor of future behavior!

It was a group originally formed to test dogs for protection abilities. Some of the testers coach pit bull owners on how to prepare for the test and recommend that those who suspect their pits won't pass, do not have their dogs take the test.

If EVERY dog of every breed was required to be tested, then the precentages would matter.

Re: the "nanny dog" nickname. Why is it that every pit bull website says that children never be left unattended with a nanny dog? Isn't that an oxymoron?

What is causing suffering and death to pit bulls is folks like you repeating that nonsense...telling the general public that this is a nanny dog has resulted in the deaths of many poor pit bulls and the mauling/deaths of some kids, too. I've been asking and waiting for someone to list where the words 'nanny dog" were used in history and no one can come up with an answer. That name is a recent addition to the pit bull propaganda.

Comment_arrow

debbie bell

7:59 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

We need to ban bad people who abuse these dogs.

Great, on that I agree. How do you propose we do that?

Steve

7:59 pm on Wednesday, August 10, 2011

Thank you Nic, nicely said. I also know of quite a few hospice centers that use pits bulls as therapy dogs. They can climb on my bed any day of the week. :) May you stay cancer free, and stay a good spokesperson for this wonderful breed of dog. God bless you and yours.

Reply

Lauren

10:59 am on Thursday, August 11, 2011

I am a local Clevelander who currently lives in a nearby suburb. As a result of some changes in our family both my sister and I (with our respective boyfriends) are planning on moving out and renting our own places in the next few months. I have an amazing Stafforshire Terrier who was rescued by the Friends of the Cleveland Kennel last year after she was found by a good samaritan infected with mange, half her needed bodyweight and wagging her tail. My sister's boyfriend has also adopted a Pit mix. Neither of us will break up our families to even consider moving to Lakewood although the prices for rent are reasonable. Here is who Lakewood is losing as possible residents: A banker, a Head Start primary level school teacher who graduated from Kent State with a 4.0, a Pack Leader at the cage-free dog daycare the Mutt Hutt and a Program Coordinator at a local non-profit who also teaches programs in Cleveland City Schools. Your laws are not hurting us, they are hurting you. They are a red flag that you have given up trying to keep your communities safe from individuals who neglect and/or abuse animals.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Chef David Edelstein M

9:29 pm on Thursday, August 11, 2011

@ Lauren... THIS is exactly the type of message breed ban cities need to hear. That they are losing out on sane and productive members in their community because of their own ignorance and ill-gotten fear. You and yours (and your integrity) are welcome in our pack anytime.

Chef David Edelstein
and Team Pit-a-Full
Denver, CO
www.TeamPitAFull.org

Randall tucker

2:42 pm on Thursday, August 11, 2011

This is to the lady Deb I believe thats her name. Not to long ago I left a job I loved four years from retirement do you know why, because the U.S government said my child Diego ( my pit bull ) thats what my wife and I consider him could not live on any Base anymore yet they allowed me to take many lives without regret. Ya know you like the government is rediculous. Its the owner not the animal its like children we pay for our raising.

Reply
Comment_arrow

debbie bell

7:05 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Sorry you had to leave your job. My suggestion on addressing the pit bull crisis is to require spay/neuter, not to confiscate or ban.

Melissa

3:44 pm on Thursday, August 11, 2011

"It is true that Pit Bulls grab and hold on. But what they most often grab and refuse to let go of is your heart, not your arm." -Vicki Hearne

Can you find the pitbull?? http://www.pitbullsontheweb.com/petbull/findpit.html
I bet quite a few city officials couldn't do it, based on the stories I have heard about them "identifying" dogs as pit bulls (Ex. A man walking his boston terrier was harassed on several occasions because animal control deemed the dog a pitbull, even after a DNA test was shown to prove the dog was no part pitbull).

Those of you who hold such a strong belief that all pit bulls are fighters...educate yourself. Often, pit bulls who are TRAINED (not bred) to fight, are also severly abused to make them mean (burns, beatings, etc.). It is not to say that there are no pit bulls that are aggressive, but there are labs that are aggressive, poodles that are aggressive, chihuahuas that are aggressive. An aggressive/dangerous dog is just that. Do not stereotype one breed because of what you think you know.

Reply
Comment_arrow

debbie bell

7:07 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

When the owner of the dog says his dog is a pit bull, I'm inclined to believe him.

When someone compares small dog bites to pit bull bites, I realize we are NOT talking about the same subject. Many children are bitten by other children, probably more than are bitten by dogs. But few children bitten by chi's or other kids need airlifted.

Comment_arrow

Melissa

9:41 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Debbie, apparently along with your inability to decipher fact from myth, you also have trouble with reading comprehension. The dog in question was a BOSTON TERRIER. The owner knew this and informed the authorities of this. The authorities, who were probably just as uneducated as you are, claimed the dog to be a pit bull, even after the owner provided DNA test results.

Gwen Lebec

2:28 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Okay, so pit bull type dogs should not be banned. What do all you pit bull fans recommend that would make neighborhoods safe, is affordable by local government, and would reduce pit bull suffering and euthanasia? All I hear is whining. How about some solutions?

Reply

debbie bell

6:48 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Excellent questions Gwen. But you won't get any answers.

You see,
thousands of dogs acquired to be used as weapons,
thousands of dogs being used in fighting,
thousands of dogs being burned alive, beaten, dismembered by their "fanciers"
thousands of neighbor dogs being shredded,(while on their own property, while being walked on a leash,)
thousands of dogs languishing in pounds, filling the dumpsters,
is all absolutely fine with the pit promoters. They have an uncanny ability to disassociate themselves from the suffering of others. Anyone who suffers from the pit bull crisis somehow made it happen to themselves, so it the victim's fault.

As long as they are the "kings" and have their adoring subject dogs, that's all that apparently matters to the pit promoters.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Chef David Edelstein M

8:28 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Hey Dimwhit... I believe the popular answer was given above (popular = the views of every animal welfare organization globally.)
Do you purposely ignore facts and direct comments or is your comprehension just THAT POOR?

debbie bell

7:02 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

I work in animal rescue. I cannot offer any hope to a homeless pit bull.
The only puppies we placed that grew up to kill their housemates were pit puppies. Every dog we placed that was severely mauled in a dog attack, were attacked by pit bulls (in our heavily pit bull populated area) It is never the dog's fault, but that means humans have to take actions to reduce their suffering and the suffering of those around the pit bulls.

Pit bull promoters are so deceptive. They say they weren't originally bred for fighting. I never said originally. It's worse, they are currently bred for fighting. I suppose that is fine with you pit pushers?

The pit pushers say "their jaws don't lock". Then why the need for a break stick? The break stick info is directly for pits. Why educate about break sticks if their don't need a break stick?

Really really hoping about something is true doens't make it true. Pits are a handicapped breed. Humans made them handicapped. As with Darla of California, she didn't know her tragically handicapped, INTACT pit bull was going to bite her. I contend he couldn't help himself. Free, mandatory spay/neuter microchipping.

Reply

debbie bell

7:14 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

Pit bull promoters are so full of it. Chef said "is typically marketing scam".

How is wanting to take steps to reduce needless dog suffering and deaths a marketing scam?

Everyone wins if there are less homeless, suffering abused dogs. Pit bulls win too.

Or are you saying: Let's breed more dogs with really bad hip displasia, idiopathic aggression, seizure disorders too, while we are at it. I really love my dog with a seizure disorder. Let's make lots more of them!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Chef David Edelstein M

8:29 pm on Sunday, August 14, 2011

nice attempt at mincing two seperate comments into one for your own BS. we are STILL NOT buying.

Peter Grossetti

9:24 am on Monday, August 15, 2011

What a shame that OUR Lakewood Patch discussion thread has been hi-jacked by out-of- towners and their childish bickering and name-calling!

Patch is supposed to be a hyper-local, community-specific news and information platform ... not a patform for uber-eager, singular-issue opponents to argue!

Reply

Ignaczi

9:36 am on Monday, August 15, 2011

Ok, I have been following all the comments on this story for a while, time for me to pipe in. My only thought is wouldn’t it be great if all of you got together and worked to come up with a solution that would satisfy both sides? If you were able to turn all of your negative, name calling and insulting comments into a positive, common goal that would make every happy we could move on and worry about other issues. There has to be a common ground somewhere, but as far as I can see, no one is even trying to find it. There isn’t anything in the world stopping all of you from coming together and working towards a positive outcome. You could even bring in a mediator or someone specializing in conflict resolution. You can quote and recite all the websites in the world regarding this issue, but the facts remain the same:
1. Dogs bite, not breed specific.
2. Laws are lenient.
3. Owners are not held responsible enough.
I can’t see how any of your banter is making this go anywhere, the issue is still there and will remain there until someone steps up and says, “Why don’t we all get together and fix this issue?” As far as I can tell, all of you are adults and should be able to work things out in an adult like manner. Food for thought:
1. Is it fair to single out a specific breed as dangerous?
2. Should the penalties for dog attacks be addressed?
3. Should owners be held more responsible for aggressive/abuse of dogs in Lakewood?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Joan Dough

10:07 am on Monday, August 15, 2011

http://www.stopk9profiling.com/calgary.php
Calgary's approach facilitates a 5 million dollar annual operating budget, at NO cost to the taxpayer. Licensing is at 98%, Zero euthanasia for population control, and a huge drop in bite stats while doubling their populous. I am sure there are people out there that will find things wrong with the Calgary Model, however I feel it is worlds better than what we have in place here in Lakewood. I have been sending the Lakewood City Council all the information needed, to no avail. Others need to step up and get active. Being vocal online is wonderful, but it takes us, as a community, to say we won't accept this any longer, if we want anything to change.

Chef David Edelstein M

1:55 pm on Monday, August 15, 2011

Why does everyone keep dancing around THE SOLUTION? Its there, its common knowledge, anyone can search the internet and find MOST cities are using it:
Generalized Dangerous Dog Ordinances that hold OWNERS (not dogs) accountable for the actions of their pets. Should there be a mandatory micro chip law for ALL ANIMALS? Yes, twice on Sundays. Should there be a mandatory spay/ neuter law for all mixed/ non-show quality/ non-licensed & bonded breeding dogs? Yes again, absolutely. Do fear mongering and propaganda websites like Dogsbite.org help our society in anyway/ shape/ or form? Not even on the best of days.
Im not sure when it happened in our culture, but somewhere along the way... seeking TRUTH and FACTS (and the source from where these truths and facts came from) seems to have become crime.
I for one am all about absolutey verifiable facts and base my opinions and views on such. Many do not share this ethic and believe everything they read in the paper/ see on the news/ hear what their friend tells them about issues. To those, you might as well have asked a 2 year old.
Here are the FACTS (not some internet trolls opinions based on fear of the unknown) about dog attacks- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G0qp6o4pPGA

Absolutely... Calgary Canada is a prime example of well thought out and implimented pet animal ordinances. Though many in the world of haters attempt to discredit BIll Bruce and his practices... the statistics and factual successes speak for themselves.

Reply

Joan Dough

2:32 pm on Monday, August 15, 2011

Thank you, David! Many of us here are fully aware of DBO's antics and how they perpetuate lies to spread their hate and fear. I truly wish we were as blessed as Colorado is with having an advocate such as yourself. Unfortunately we are stuck, as many cities, cleaning up the mess the City Council has made thanks in part to zealots like Colleen and her minions. I for one appreciate "out of towners" who comment, as long as they provide something constructive to aid with the problems, rather than fear mongering and hate. I admire all you have done, all your hard work to educate the populous. Can I clone you?

Reply

Steve

6:55 pm on Monday, August 15, 2011

What is wrong with Clevelands rewritten Ord. ? I like it much better than Lakewoods, it addresses the real issue's at hand. Any comment???

Reply
Comment_arrow

Joan Dough

8:11 pm on Monday, August 15, 2011

Steve, Cleveland's rewrite and going breed neutral is awesome! The only problem with using it is Lakewood City Council always says they want proof of what works and with Cleveland's ordinance being new, I have a feeling they would try to use that against going with it or at least refuse to look at it if we bring it to them as a guide to follow. Calgary has a proven track record, (as do many other breed neutral Cities), and that is why I brought it up.

Comment_arrow

Steve

10:03 am on Tuesday, August 16, 2011

Joan, what will be the consiquences if/when HB-14 passes through the senate and signed by the governor, as it seems to reflect the cleveland ord. Will that trumph Lakewoods Ord.?

Peter Grossetti

10:15 am on Tuesday, August 16, 2011

Steve - This is the preamble from City Council Charter of the City:

"We, the people of the City of Lakewood, in the County of Cuyahoga and State of Ohio, in order that we may have the benefits of municipal home rule and exercise all the powers of local self-government, do frame and adopt this Charter for the government of the City."

I have been told that "HOME RULE" means (essentialy) "we make our our rules regardless of what state or federal laws/rules state."

If anyone can shed any further light on this I'm all ears.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Kristi

8:36 am on Wednesday, August 17, 2011

Peter - I think I can shed some light on the Home Rule discussion. Ohio's Home Rule Doctrine can be found in the Ohio Constitution (Article 3, Section 18 I believe), which essentially provides that a municipality (such as Lakewood) can pass laws which do not conflict with the laws of the state of Ohio. So, if someone from Lakewood said "we make our own rules regardless of what state or federal laws/rules state", that is absolutely false. For example, in my opinion (and this is part of the bases for one of the lawsuits currently pending against Lakewood), the fact that Lakewood requires all pit bulls to be muzzled while off the owner's property conflicts with Home Rule and is therefore unconstutitional because under Ohio law (O.R.C. 955.22(D)), an owner is not required to have his pit bull muzzled while off his property as long as the owner follows theother specified requirements. So, in every other city in the State of Ohio (except those with simillarly unconstitutional ordinances as Lakewood), like my city, I can walk my pit bull down the street without a muzzle and it is legal to do so, but if I bring my dog into Lakewood and walk her down the street without a muzzle, it's illegal. That, by definition, is a conflict with state law. Another example can be found in O.R.C. 955.22(D) which permits my pit bull to be secured in my locked, fenced yard while on my property. Lakewood, on the other hand, requires all pit bulls to be confined in a pen with 6' sides, etc.

Chef David Edelstein M

10:53 am on Tuesday, August 16, 2011

Steve... thats almost verbatum of Home Rule Authority here in Denver. I dont know about Lakewood, Ohio... but Denver's Home Rule is THE ONLY foundation for the pit bull ban to this day. No expert witnesses, no untampered with or unmanipulated dog bite statistics or data, no unmanipulated public surveys, nothing. So, from an outsider/ non-bias person's opinion... one could safely say that a city like Lakewood, Ohio or Denver, CO bases their ban on Pit bulls soley on Ego and not absolute, sensible public safety practices.
Denver's city council BIG MOUTH, Chuck "My ego is 20 times bigger than yours" Brown has repeatedly stated "we are a Home Rule Charter city and we will not be bullied by the state or federal government." He makes no bones about this is ALL ABOUT power and not public safety.

Reply

Joan Dough

11:16 am on Tuesday, August 16, 2011

That sounds so familiar. Here is a small portion of what we were just told by Shawn Juris, Lakewood City Councilman,"I'm familiar with SB14 and that it WON'T change the course for Lakewood". He also said,if the safety measures in place still " Leave a high level of fear (REAL OR PERCEIVED) ...the city can and did chose to avoid the risk" "Now maybe the rest of the city council can be convinced that the decision to ban Pit Bulls should be overturned, I am still in favor of keeping this in force".
So, in a nutshell, this is what we are up against.

Reply

Jo Angle Staats

11:18 am on Tuesday, August 16, 2011

Most state code(s) indicate the HOME RULE power is viable but must also prove enforceable. If Lakewood residents can demonstrate that a particular local law (that supersedes or exceeds state law) is not being enforced then there is ground for change. I would highly recommend contacting Lucas County Pit Crew organization for more information about HB14, and all Ohio related Home Rule influence. Lakewood has a bully owners org as well that can be found on FB Steve.

Reply

Steve

11:42 am on Tuesday, August 16, 2011

Thanks for all the reply's. I am going to dig deeper into this mess as I find there is usually a back door solution to every problem. Thanks again all, :-)

Reply
Comment_arrow

Joan Dough

7:46 pm on Sunday, August 21, 2011

That's the correct email. If you copied and pasted it, try typing it in. Sometimes that works. lakewood pittie committee @ live . com :) Look forward to hearing from you!

Comment_arrow

Steve

6:25 pm on Sunday, August 21, 2011

Joan. I tried to reach you at the above address, but it came back. Is that the correct e-mail???
lakewoodpittiecommitte@live.com

Comment_arrow

Joan Dough

7:47 pm on Sunday, August 21, 2011

I see the problem, left of an e. My apologies.

Chef David Edelstein M

4:48 pm on Tuesday, August 16, 2011

Steve... what ever you find... please share with us as well. BSL is not a Lakewood, OH problem... its global problem and we all need to share both our failures and successes in fighting this blatant stupidity. Info@TeamPitAFull.org

Reply
Comment_arrow

Kristi

8:42 am on Wednesday, August 17, 2011

Steve - just a reminder that home rule authority varies from state to state. So, what may violate home rule in Ohio may not violate home rule in Colorado, for example. That's because whether a violation exists depends on (1) the language of the state Constitution at issue; and (2) the laws of the state at issue. Obviously, these things are or may be different from state to state.

Sarah Kuhl

4:21 am on Monday, September 5, 2011

It seems as though I've come across this blog a little late. It appears that the real "issue" has finally shut it's ignorant mouth.
Chef-You rock. Intelligent, responsible and willing to stand up for our babies, our pit bulls.
Debbie, you are whats wrong with this world. You are what lead to the holocaust and slavery. You are an ignorant, stupid and useless being in this world. You should be spayed and let allow to go into extinction, YOU and everyone like you. People like you believe that 'all African Americans are drug dealers' and every 'Hispanic person is an illegal immigrant'. You are why there is racisim and discrimination. Well now that I've let out some frustration ... I will share with you my "pit bull" experience.

Reply

Sarah Kuhl

4:30 am on Monday, September 5, 2011

I have been bit my two dogs in my life. A golden retriever almost ripped my ear off and a "friendliest dog of the month" award winning dalmatian attacked my face. I have two Pittys. One is not neutered due to a heart condition and the other was taken from his mother at 4 weeks and given away online. I would give my life for them because I KNOW they would give there lives for me. There is a love and bond so strong between a Pit Bull and it's owner that you and simpleminded idiots like you are not capable of feeling. I have had animals around me my entire life but NEVER have I felt the love, devotion and sweetness from any other animal. I trust both of my boys completely. My heart hurts for them. I have seen people leave the dog park when they saw my boys. I have watched them be kicked for getting near other dogs at the dog park. They cannot speak for themselves. So (and this is being kind) go to hell. Go back into your cave and live in your stupid little world. If you want to see what a "Pit Bull" really is I'd be more than happy to let you meet my boys. Unlike you though they will not judge you based on how you look or who your ancestors were. They don't care. Their love is unconditional ...
Ps. Don't reproduce.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Chef David Edelstein M

10:05 am on Monday, September 5, 2011

@ Sarah Kuhl... WOW!!! Could this world use about half a billion of your clone or what? Not many of us are willing to genuinely draw a line inthe sand and HOLD THAT LINE. Sarah... answer me this: I believe we all start off very equal and on the same plain in life. We all have birthdays, we all have family and friends, we all have life experiences, hopefully we all get the opportunity to get a decent education and get jobs and start families of our own. Where does this sub-culture stray? Its as if they got differnt text books than the rest of us. Its as if they attended some OTHER critical thinking and philosophy classes. OR... is it a matter of they are incapable and standing back from ANY social issue and examing ALL possible reasons/ particulars/ cause/ solutions/ etc? Humans are allegedly the top of the food chain, opposing thumbs, standing/walking up-right, etc. Yet, some have the intelligence level LOWER than a single cell. How does this happen if we all start off as equals?

Sarah Kuhl

10:18 am on Monday, September 5, 2011

We are now best friends .... I am so furious right now. I allowed myself to read some of the BS that a "for-the-victims" websites posts. People are so stupid. Does anyone know what an American Pit Bull Terrier even is? They are not 150lbs. UKC CLEARLY states that 60lbs is the max weight and anything "too large" is a disqualification. As living beings on this planet the only thing we have that other living beings do not possess is the ability to think and convince ourselves that we are more intelligent and better than all other living beings. Dogs don't have war, rape, abuse ... etc. We do. This does not make us more intelligent just because we have the capability of experiencing different feelings.

A) If you want to say pits are bad F off ... we created them now they will stay here. Also ... find out if it's a "pit" in the first place. AHH that's right ... there is only ONE way (that has been proven highly unsuccessful) of proving your dog could be a pit. Go pay $200 and get a DNA test to find out MAYBE that there is a slight amount of American Staffordshire Terrier in him. Our world is completely gone to shit. We have allowed ourselves to conform to what our government/media wants us to believe.
We have stopped questioning a thing and we have stopped standing up for the truth. Instead we have allowed ourselves to blame everything else in attempts to not see what we have all really become.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Chef David Edelstein M

10:34 am on Monday, September 5, 2011

I just dont get it. The lack of basic mathematics, the lack of basic logic. Do people go out of their way to figure 1+1= 540? Or is it instilled into them with basic fear and "shoving one's head in the sand" as the government and media tells them to?

Sarah Kuhl

10:40 am on Monday, September 5, 2011

I don't know. My husband says I get too worked up over things. I was told by my fathers girlfriend that my "angry Facebook posts" upset her and I should find other ways to "help pit bulls". She is someone who is very politically active ... and she is telling me not to get angry. Everyone is just a huge hypocrite it seems. Unfortunately only a few of us can see how F everything and everyone really is. Some of us are medicated to calm down and unemployed because we cannot watch as lies turn into accepted norms ....

Reply

Sarah Kuhl

10:43 am on Monday, September 5, 2011

That is how I know we are not the most intelligent things on earth ... We'll all end up dead from anxiety or from killing one another ... and all the little pit bulls will roam free from us and people like that woman that was trying to make her life seem like it has a purpose by standing up for something that is obviously completely BS

Reply

Leave a comment