patching...
Update: Get Lakewood news first and free: Sign up for the Lakewood Patch newsletter here. »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

POLL: Recycling Bins or Blue Bags?

The city is eyeing a plan that would distribute 96-gallon recycling bins to residents, starting in 2013.

 

Last week, the city began discussing the possibility of distributing 96-gallon recycling bins to residents, starting in 2013.

The nearly $1 million plan would be implemented in three phases. 

Instead of loading recyclables into blue bags and placing them on the curb, residents could toss all recyclable materials into the new bins.

Lakewood City Council is slated to vote on that — and other 2013 budget issues — at its Dec. 17 meeting.

There’d be a large initial investment, but city officials believe that an automated system could save as much as $100,000 per year.

There were dozens of comments on the post and many more on the Lakewood Patch’s Facebook page (by the way, you should “like” it).

We thought we’d put it to a poll.

Do you support the city’s proposed new recycling initiative?

  • Do you support the city’s proposed new recycling initiative?

    (Voting has been closed for this question)
    • Yes, we should definitely have curbside recycling bins
        66 (78%)
    • No, keeping bagging ‘em up.
        16 (19%)
    • Other (tell us in the comments)
        2 (2%)
    Total votes: 84
  • Your vote will only count once. This is not a scientific poll. View Results Vote!
Related Topics: Lakewood Refuse and Recycling, Lakewood recycling, Recycling, and Recycling Bins

Denny Prochaska

6:46 am on Sunday, December 9, 2012

The wave of the future is the blue totes... I also think this would drive more residents to recycling.

Reply

Ruth

6:56 am on Sunday, December 9, 2012

Too bad about the cost but it would be more convenient than buying those recycle blue bags or using multiple store bags. Would not have to put it out weekly since the bins are so large. Would be less trash flying around the street also.

Reply

Shannon Hoffman

7:01 am on Sunday, December 9, 2012

Give me the bin. I hate the blue bags because I use cloth bags at the store and it seems counterproductive to get bags just so I can recycle other stuff.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Kim Tylicki

8:58 am on Sunday, December 9, 2012

Shannon, that is my thought entirely. I love the idea of the bins!

Diane G

8:25 am on Sunday, December 9, 2012

I think the 96 gallon containers would be bigger than needed. There are smaller versions that have wheels. Carrying a tote or bin would be hard for some seniors and those with disabilities.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Michael A. Miller

9:15 am on Monday, December 10, 2012

I thought they were going to be the little square ones with the notches cut out, like the old potato bins. If they're the 96-gallon ones, they won't do me any good because I'll have to use a bag to contain recyclables until it's time to take them down (from the upstairs of a double), or run downstairs every time I empty a can or jar.

Denny Prochaska

8:32 am on Sunday, December 9, 2012

Check out what fairview park does... They have the large one for trash and a smaller can on wheels for recycling.

Also, are their any concerns with residents not putting out on a weekly basis and accumulating their recyclables as far as optimizing the work force consistently?

Reply

Michael Martini

9:12 am on Sunday, December 9, 2012

Question to those of you voting for the bins...if you had to buy the bin yourself, would you still be voting for it? I just think that sometimes people think that things like this are free, but you are paying for it with your taxes. I just think the money could be better spent somewhere else, that's just my two cents.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Michael A. Miller

3:36 pm on Sunday, December 9, 2012

Had we been allowed to use the blue bins in the past (I inquired about them some time ago), I would have gladly bought one.

Comment_arrow

Emily Lindberg

6:25 pm on Monday, December 10, 2012

yes i would buy one either directly or with my tax money. Those bags just get blown around the city, causing litter. And like Shannon said above, many people are using reusable shopping bags, so why create unnecessary waste? The bins will last for years. Besides, did you miss the part where they will ultimately SAVE the city money in the long run?

Comment_arrow

Samuel Francazio

9:28 pm on Friday, December 14, 2012

I plan to live in Lakewood for a while and would invest in buying the bin though taxes, it should pay off before I retire to Florida, I wish!

Comment_arrow

Shelley

8:00 pm on Monday, December 17, 2012

The city makes quite a bit of money selling the recyclables. Years ago when they 1st started taking just 1&2 plastics they sent a newsletter that they made 1/4 million. Now that they take everything, and the point of the bins is to encourage people to recycle more, I believe the point is to make our tax $ back & profit more.

Comment_arrow

Ric Rada

6:07 am on Saturday, February 9, 2013

Yes, I would be willing to pay a one time fee rather than having to purchase recycling bags from the store, sooner or later there would be a payoff, but more importantly I feel more people would be likely to recycle items rather than just tossing those items in the trash bin! Ever since I started recycling in earnest, I found out that I only put my trash can out about once a month, but have anywhere from 2 to 3 large blue recycling bags out every week. I like the idea of reducing the amount of stuff going into landfills.

Denny Prochaska

9:21 am on Sunday, December 9, 2012

Good question... I would have to say yes. The cost of the blue bags is pretty high.

Reply

Alexandra

9:26 am on Sunday, December 9, 2012

Moving here from CA I say BINS, much easier and gets more people to recycle, most in Lakewood do not live in big houses and to put our recyclables, as we did in San Diego, in the big blue bin makes utter sense. Now please people bring ALL your bins in on your trash day, sick of lazy people who cannot take 3 minutes to pull up a bin or 2

Reply

Alexandra

9:32 am on Sunday, December 9, 2012

Mr. Martini, our taxes are going to pay for them like it or not. After many posts you live here but do not seem to actually like it, you can move to a more suitable suburb, perhaps the Eastern suburbs are more to your liking...Lakewood has the highest taxes in the region...if you LOVE benefits you should adore this. The bins, are more convinient for the mass population. Why not just do or vote for something that overall benefits? Personally I fed UP with blue bags, bite me, I am from CA, we invented recyling

Reply

Kimberly

9:59 am on Sunday, December 9, 2012

I live on one of the narrowest streets in Lakewood. My tree lawn is approx 2 feet wide. So 2 huge garbage receptacles on my non existing tree lawn, NO thank you.

Reply

Kelly

10:20 am on Sunday, December 9, 2012

Our family recycles everything possible. Besides glass, metal, plastic, cardboard - don't forget ALL paper. Junkmail, etc. We compost kitchen scraps. This leaves us w/just 1 or 2 bags per week of garbage. Our recyclables are more than our garbage. I love the idea of bins. We don't have enough room in our house or garage to keep all the recycling garbage & a bin would be great. In my opinion, if you have way more garbage than recycling, you are not recycling all you could. There are exceptions I.e., baby diapers. In our family a bin would take up the same space than the blue bags.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Emily Lindberg

6:33 pm on Monday, December 10, 2012

I totally agree with this statement. But since you brought up disposable diapers...as a friendly reminder, poop goes in the toilet, not the trash :) Oh yeah, and diapers should NEVER be left all by themselves on the cub. that's just nasty!

Penny

10:57 am on Sunday, December 9, 2012

I don't much like buying the blue bags but to have to try to deal with yet another huge container all week is more than annoying. I prefer the bags. My property is extremely small and jockeying the containers around my car all week will be very inconvenient not to mention unsightly.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Emily Lindberg

6:37 pm on Monday, December 10, 2012

I totally understand that space is a major concern for many Lakewood residence. But do remember that a bin does not need to be taken to the curb every week. Depending on your situation, you could possibly alternate putting out the recycling bin with taking out the trash bin on a weekly basis.

Nick

11:03 am on Sunday, December 9, 2012

I support curbside recycling to get rid of the bags...Let's go one step further and put a tax on plastic bags at the grocery store. I think Washington DC imposed a $0.05 a bag tax to cut down on the waste.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Emily Lindberg

6:41 pm on Monday, December 10, 2012

Yes, a bag tax should have been in place years ago. Such a tax exists in Ireland and it seemed like no one was walking out of shops with arm-fulls of plastic like what you see here.

Pico

11:56 am on Sunday, December 9, 2012

I have the iconic Lakewood one car small garage. There just isn't any room in it for the new garbage can, let alone a recycle bin, which means the recycle one will probably be left out with the garbage bin on my driveway. Before, my smaller trashcan always made it back into the garage but now I have to leave the big one out and I am not looking forward to a big blue one sitting out next to it.

Reply

Terry Meehan

12:24 pm on Sunday, December 9, 2012

This is a no-brainer. More people would recycle and the city would make money.

Reply

Hol

3:30 pm on Sunday, December 9, 2012

If there were a smaller bin available...I would be all for it. But a 96 gallon container....seems like a big expense and Lakewood has one of the highest tax rates in NEOH as it is!

Reply

Candi Parry

3:53 pm on Sunday, December 9, 2012

I am also for the bins . . . 'tho I do agree that 96 gallon is excessive!! We had mandatory recycling back in PA 40 years ago! Garbage was collected TWICE weekly, recycles ONCE a week. We more recently had SMALL bins in Indianapolis, that we paid $25. for. I would happily purchase a bin (recommend a smaller size), I hate buying the plastic bags . . . a one time purchase for a container makes MUCH more sense to me!

Reply

Gold Coast Block Watch

4:04 pm on Sunday, December 9, 2012

I like the smaller blue bin idea. There are many persons in the apartment buildings around me that recycle using the blue bags. Will their buildings receive a bin?

Reply

Janice Snyder

6:32 pm on Sunday, December 9, 2012

I'm all for the blue bags...are you going to go outside to the 96-gallon bin every time you use a can or a bottle? We have a "dedicated blue bag" in a waste basket for recyclables under the kitchen sink. Once it's filled, it goes out on the curb the night before our garbage pick-up. No fuss. No muss.

Reply

Denny Prochaska

6:36 pm on Sunday, December 9, 2012

Each family could figure out the logistics behind how they keep their recyclables. I would just take out just like trash... When the can fills up in the kitchen, take it out to the large can.

Reply

Julie Hutchison

7:20 pm on Sunday, December 9, 2012

I was just thinking this week. Out loud. To myself. That if recycling is mandatory, why do they give us huge garbage bins, but no recycling bin at all? I barely use my garbage bin. I am so happy that they are planning this and I vote yes 100%
Also, when will they start curbside compost pick up?

Reply
Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Colin McEwen

11:06 pm on Sunday, December 9, 2012

The first of three phases is set to begin in 2013. That is, if council passes this budget measure with the rest of 'em on Dec. 17.

Comment_arrow

Emily Lindberg

6:56 pm on Monday, December 10, 2012

Totally, 100% agree. And to the people who are proposing a smaller bin, that just doesn't make sense to me. There are WAY more "disposable" household items that are recyclable than not. Now curbside composting is what we REALLY need to start doing! However, I do have one suggestion for any new bins. Please have explicit instructions for what items CAN AND CANNOT go into them printed directly on the bins. We want recycling/ composting to be as easy as "trashing" but everyone needs to be on the same page so as to lessen the chances of contamination.

DLSJR

7:50 pm on Sunday, December 9, 2012

On one hand the idea is good, on the other hand this is going to cost me and other property owners like me more money. I own a 7 unit apt building, and when the city went to the automated trash pick up they cut our service. I ask my 8 tenants to recycle everything, and also supply compost bins for them. By doing this I'm able to save $50 a month and have my three 96 gal bins pick up every other week instead of weekly. I do not want another city service cut unless the city lowers my taxes this time.

Reply

Barbara Greene

10:41 pm on Sunday, December 9, 2012

There was mention of banning street parking on trash days to accommodate the new automated recycling. We can only park on one side of the street now and there's not nearly enough of that already. Also, the automated pickup saves the city money by cutting jobs, and we don't need that.

Reply

Samuel Francazio

11:34 pm on Sunday, December 9, 2012

My cellar is a dump from recycle Glass, Plastic, Cardboard ect. and it makes are City a dump, with blue bags blowing everywhere from the Wind! Good idea with new bins

Reply

Bob Bellamy

11:35 pm on Sunday, December 9, 2012

Smaller bins than what is being proposed!!!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Judy Towner

11:23 am on Monday, December 10, 2012

Come on Bob, I know you have lots of "stuff" to recycle!!!

Gina J.

7:04 am on Monday, December 10, 2012

bins for sure! on windy winter nights it is given that everyones blue bags full of recyclables is strewn around the neighborhood-show some pride council

Reply

Christina Cocchiarale Ward

10:12 am on Monday, December 10, 2012

Blue bags for sure. I just don't see how we can justify spending money on bins when there are other important things that money should be spent on. Ridiculous.

Reply
Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Colin McEwen

7:05 pm on Monday, December 10, 2012

Just to be clear, the idea of the initiative is to save money in the long-run — to the tune of about $100,000 per year. The city receives money for recycling, but has to shell out for garbage (think landfills).

Tate Davidson

10:54 am on Monday, December 10, 2012

OK here's an alternative solution:
Have recycling pickup the day after trash pickup. Then the same bin can be used for recycling and trash. People with collect recycling in the usual spot in their house or whatever and then drop it in the bin the night after the trash is picked up.
No more bins are needed!

Reply

Michele Marotta

1:57 pm on Monday, December 10, 2012

I think the bins would be a better fit for our lovely city! I for one am sick of dodging small recycling bags as I drive down side streets after a windy night. OR running after them as they leave my curb. Maybe if we had the bins, people would use their grocery bags for picking up after their dogs!

Reply

Samuel Francazio

11:53 pm on Monday, December 10, 2012

If the Recycle Bins are big enough, Maybe two times a week, or maybe once a month on the tree lawn !?.

Reply

Karin Zimmermann

12:37 pm on Tuesday, December 11, 2012

I would be happy to have a recycle bin if it came in a smaller size. My family recycles everything we can but do not have the space in our yard for another 96 gallon bin.

Reply

pamann

12:38 pm on Tuesday, December 11, 2012

I agree that something needs to be done but Lakewood has small yards and not only am I sick of looking at my trashcan but my neighbors as well. I think my yard would be a real eyesore with another big plastic can. And I know there are smaller ones available. But in the long run I say yes.

Reply

Shelley

10:05 am on Friday, December 14, 2012

96 gals is HUGE unless they are cheaper to buy that way or pick them up bi weekly. Better than dodging the blue bags blown all over the street. And I am basementless w 1000 sq feet. Have a can I put my blue bags in already then take them out and carry to street as I have NO indoor space for this. Would be lovely just to wheel the can to the curb :)

Reply

DLSJR

12:04 pm on Friday, December 14, 2012

To try to prevent ones bags from blowing around, tie them together like Lakewood's website recommends we do. Maybe ask a neighbor to tie bags together. We are still going to have to bag our recyclables and put them in side the can. Has anyone really thought where are multi family homes going to store 4-8 bins (recycling and trash) in their back yard, and or put on their small tree lawn/curb? How are the trucks going to be able to pick up 2-8 bins every 50ft (guessing on average property width) with parked cars and soon snow from the plows? Living on Clifton, I do not see how the current automated trash system is saving time/money, besides cutting labor and commercial property pick up. Almost every week from my window I see the truck driver trying to parallel park in between cars on Clifton. Then the driver will get out of the truck and either bring the bin to, or walks the bins back to the sidewalk. Maybe the city could put the money they would spend on equipping current trucks or buying new on the city's waste water system.. Just my thought

Reply
Comment_arrow

Shelley

8:15 pm on Monday, December 17, 2012

I'm with you on the auto trash system! It only works on one side of the street. On the side where cars park that I live on they can not use it. That is at least half of the city. If I had a wish for a new city truck I would wish for a leaf vacuum truck. I have never seen each side street shut down completely, a back hoe, a dump truck, 4 people with leaf blowers and 2 drivers and half an hour to get leaves off of 1 block. The gas pollution, noise pollution, inconvenience. I moved here in 95 had always lived where they ran vacuum trucks around every street like a clock. This is almost comical it is so archaic and wasteful.

Christina Cocchiarale Ward

8:51 am on Tuesday, December 18, 2012

Trash CAN be picked up where there's cars. Driveways is where you are suppose to put them then. I've seen the trash guys do both sides of my street and there's cars around. People use open spaces.

Reply

Leave a comment